| Base Material | 15% | Material certificate should identify grade, chemical composition, heat number, and applicable standard. | 304 stainless steel; heat traceability | 316 stainless steel; heat traceability | 304 stainless steel; partial records | Carbon steel; zinc plated |
| Seal Material Compatibility | 10% | Seal compound should be selected according to temperature, fluid exposure, pressure, and regulatory requirements. | EPDM; -40°C to 150°C | FKM; -20°C to 200°C | NBR; -30°C to 100°C | EPDM; -40°C to 120°C |
| Material Certification | 8% | Current EN 10204 inspection documents or equivalent test certificates should be available for each material lot. | 3.1 certificate available | 3.1 certificate available | 3.1 certificate on request | 2.2 declaration only |
| Dimensional Control | 12% | Inspection should cover thread diameter, pitch, head dimensions, sealing surface, and critical tolerances. | Cpk ≥ 1.33 on critical dimensions | Cpk ≥ 1.67 on critical dimensions | Cpk 1.20–1.32 | Final inspection only |
| Thread and Torque Performance | 10% | Supplier should provide torque-tension results, thread-gauge records, and installation recommendations. | Torque test per production lot | Torque and prevailing-torque data | Torque test by sampling | Basic thread inspection |
| Leak and Pressure Testing | 15% | Testing should use a documented pressure, duration, medium, and acceptance criterion suitable for the application. | 100% air-leak test; 5 bar; 30 s | 100% air-leak test; 10 bar; 60 s | Sampling test; 5 bar; 30 s | Visual inspection only |
| Manufacturing Quality System | 10% | A valid ISO 9001 certificate should cover the relevant manufacturing and inspection scope. | ISO 9001 certified | ISO 9001 certified; automotive procedures | ISO 9001 certified | Quality system not independently certified |
| Applicable Compliance | 8% | Relevant declarations may include RoHS, REACH, conflict-minerals information, and sector-specific requirements. | RoHS and REACH declarations | RoHS, REACH, and material disclosure | RoHS declaration only | Declarations unavailable |
| Traceability and Documentation | 7% | Each shipment should be traceable to raw material, production batch, inspection results, and packaging label. | Lot-level traceability | Lot-level traceability with digital records | Batch traceability | Basic invoice traceability |
| Surface Finish and Corrosion Protection | 5% | Surface treatment, coating thickness, passivation, and corrosion-test requirements should match the service environment. | Passivated stainless steel | Passivated stainless steel | Passivation controlled by batch | Zinc plating; 8–12 μm |
| Nonconformance and Corrective Action | 5% | Supplier should use documented root-cause analysis and corrective-action procedures, such as an 8D report. | 8D response within 10 working days | 8D response within 5 working days | Corrective-action report available | Case-by-case response |
| Delivery Capability | 5% | Evaluate quoted lead time, minimum order quantity, capacity, and historical on-time delivery performance. | 4–6 weeks; 96% on-time delivery | 5–7 weeks; 98% on-time delivery | 3–5 weeks; 91% on-time delivery | 2–4 weeks; 84% on-time delivery |